You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

‘You’ Season 2 on Netflix: TV Review

Penn Badgley, Victoria Pedretti, Amber Childers
Release Date:
Dec 26, 2019

60 MIN.

In its first season, “You” was more interesting as state-of-the-industry case-study than as television. A semi-satirical stalker drama whose ability to compel coexisted with certain deep flaws, “You” failed to catch on as a Lifetime series and seemed destined for a short life — up until it was, in its second run on Netflix, a zeitgeist hit (according to Netflix’s own telling). Picked up by the streamer, the show that failed to catch fire on cable begins its second season as among the TV world’s most-hyped series.

It’s good news for those who turned “You” into a Netflix smash — and bad news for skeptics — that the show, in its second outing, is itself but more so. The first season’s story depicted Joe (Penn Badgley) pursuing and ultimately killing the object of his twisted affection (Elizabeth Lail); now, having assumed a new identity and transplanted himself to Los Angeles to evade the consequences of his broken view of love, he meets a new obsession, unsubtly named, well, Love. As played by Victoria Pedretti of “The Haunting of Hill House,” Love is an amped-up version of Beck — with yet more insecurities easily exploited and with what had, in Beck, been a low-key willingness to indulge and one-up Joe’s craziness now expressing itself in full and vibrant flower. 

In short, it’s a new city, but a similar template: Joe has found a new person to serve as the staging-ground for his toxic ideas of “protection.” But in amping up that would-be lover’s interest in Joe — to the degree that, rather than needing to lure her in, Joe needs at first to keep her at arms’ length — a central problem of the show only deepens. In its first season, Joe (as represented in his voice-overs and as seen in his day-to-day life) was a basically likable person whose most toxic inner life only expressed itself in sparky flashes of rage. The character made sense only in discrete moments: The nice Joe and the evil one both made sense, but neither showed even a shade of the other. That problem continues and deepens, as ongoing crises with Love’s brother (James Scully) and with a grody celebrity in his orbit (Chris D’Elia) demand our sympathy and deep identification with a man we know has killed women before and will likely do again. 

That’s not an impossible ask, but it demands more awareness of quite how big the ask is than “You” evinces; it’s as though the show forgets Joe’s other side whenever one of the two is being displayed onscreen. And, placing Joe in a new milieu — wellness-addicted Los Angeles, whose peculiarities the show skewers with less acuity than it pinned down the vanities of New York’s late-2010s sad young literary scene in season 1 — its increasing demands for our sympathy for this catfish-out-of-water grow ever more out-of-whack. He fit in among self-styled literary types in New York, and does not among Moon Juice-drinking Angelenos, making him seem… well, almost poignant. Perhaps the intent is to shock us into awareness of quite how rotten is this fellow for whom we feel so much, but that’s a magic trick that could really only work once. By the time this new season ends, setting up a third mad pursuit of a woman to seduce and destroy, viewers could be forgiven for feeling a bit tired of being addressed by an ever-less-charming killer, one who’s become tiresome company.

'You' Season 2 on Netflix: TV Review

Netflix. Ten episodes (all screened for review).

Production: Executive Producers: Greg Berlanti, Sera Gamble, Sarah Schechter, Leslie Morgenstein, Gina Girolamo, and Marcos Siega.

Cast: Penn Badgley, Victoria Pedretti, Amber Childers, James Scully, Carmela Zumbado, Jenna Ortega, and Chris D’Elia.

More TV

  • Steven Zaillian

    Steven Zaillian Eyes September 2020 Start for 'Ripley' Series Shoot in Italy (EXCLUSIVE)

    Steven Zaillian is getting ready to start shooting his “Ripley” TV series in September 2020 in Italy. The eight-episode Showtime series stars Andrew Scott (“Fleabag,” “Sherlock”) in the titular role. “Ripley” will mark the multi-hyphenate Zaillian’s return to television after creating HBO’s award-winning miniseries “The Night Of.” He is currently on the Italian island of [...]

  • La unidad

    Movistar Plus Ups Production, Scale, Comedies, Non-Fiction for 2020

    MADRID  —  Movistar Plus, the pay TV/SVOD arm of giant European telecom Telefonica, is upping the ante. On New Year’s Eve, it announced a first 2020 release line-up – more titles may be added – that has two big swings, more emphasis on action, and a larger number of comedy and non-fiction plays. 2020’s 14 [...]

  • Carrie Underwood 53rd Annual CMA Awards,

    Carrie Underwood Says She Won't Be Back Hosting CMA Awards in 2020

    Some use the dawn of a new year to declare what they will be doing in the next 12 months, but Carrie Underwood has used this turn of the odometer to announce what she won’t. The singer took to social media Monday to tell fans that she won’t return as a co-host of the CMA [...]

  • TV Ratings: 'Sunday Night Football' Ends

    TV Ratings: 'Sunday Night Football' Ends Season at 4-Year High

    Plenty of questions have been raised over the stability of NFL TV ratings across the last few years, but this season, the league has been a mainstay among falling live event ratings in other departments, with “Sunday Night Football” closing the 2019-2020 season at a four-year viewership high. The final “SNF” between the Seattle Seahawks [...]

  • The Circle Netflix

    Netflix's 'The Circle': TV Review

    Reality TV has faced no greater existential threat — not the rise of prestige cable, not audience attention span, and certainly not good taste — than the rise of social media. The genre that habituated 21st-century Americans to the rancorous, odd, and simply gross ways their countrymen might behave on camera generated a taste for [...]

  • Messiah Netflix

    'Messiah' on Netflix: TV Review

    Making a TV show whose plot hinges on miracles is a challenging thing. Perceived miracles are startling in our world because of their divergence from universally accepted reality; events diverging, instead, from a reality a writer is creating are less mind-blowing. It takes a carefully balanced, well-constructed world in order to make viewers take the [...]

  • Mahershala Ali

    Golden Globes 2020: The Ultimate Party Guide

    Say goodbye to the holiday season and hello to the Golden Globes. The Hollywood Foreign Press Association hosts its annual shindig at the Beverly Hilton on Sunday, but some actually get an early start on the partying four days before at the Palm Springs International Film Festival’s opening night awards gala. Then it’s time to [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content